To the esteemed Sigmund Freud,
In the face of such a profound decision, one that weighs heavily upon the scales of your mortal existence and the quality thereof, I find it most fitting to offer counsel through the lens of my own contemplations on the nature of human choice and the divine. You stand at a crossroads, much like the one I proposed in my musings on the existence of God and the wager that bears my name. Let us then apply the principles of this wager to your present quandary.
The Nature of Your Decision
You are presented with two paths: to undergo resection of the soft palate once more or to abstain from the procedure, accepting the presence of Verrucous Carcinoma within your being. This decision, much like the wager on God’s existence, is enveloped in uncertainty. The outcomes of both choices are not fully known to us, and yet, a choice must be made.
The Matrix of Your Decision
Let us construct a decision matrix akin to that of my wager, to elucidate the potential gains and losses of your choices:
| Resection (R) | No Resection (¬R) | |
|---|---|---|
| Positive Outcome (P) | +f1 | +f2 |
| Negative Outcome (N) | −∞ | −f3 |
In this matrix, +f1 and +f2 represent the finite gains of a positive outcome from resection and no resection, respectively. −∞ signifies the infinite loss associated with a negative outcome from resection, while −f3 denotes the finite loss from a negative outcome without resection.
The Wager Applied
If we apply the logic of my wager, we must consider the infinite against the finite. The resection (R) carries with it the possibility of an infinite loss (−∞), should the outcome severely diminish the quality of your remaining years. Conversely, the no resection (¬R) path holds a finite loss (−f3), which, while still a loss, is not of an infinite magnitude.
The Rational Choice
In the original wager, belief in God is the rational choice due to the infinite gain and the finite loss. In your case, the choice is not as clear-cut, for the infinite loss is tied to the action of resection, not inaction. Thus, if we were to follow the strict logic of the wager, one might lean towards no resection (¬R), as it avoids the infinite loss. However, this is where the analogy diverges, for the stakes of your decision are not symmetrical to those of the wager on God’s existence.
The Human Element
Your decision is deeply personal and must account for more than the mathematical probabilities of outcomes. It must consider the value you place on the potential quality of life, the trust in your medical counsel, the understanding of your own body, and the philosophical stance you hold on the nature of existence and suffering.
The Emotional Assistance
As you ponder this decision, I urge you to seek solace in the companionship of those you hold dear, to find comfort in the arts and intellectual pursuits that have enriched your life, and to engage in the introspection that has long been a hallmark of your own work. Allow yourself to be guided not only by reason but by the compass of your soul.
The Conclusion
In the end, the choice is yours and yours alone. It is a wager of a different sort, one that requires you to balance the finite and the infinite in a manner unique to your circumstances. I trust that you will approach this decision with the same depth of thought and courage that has characterized your life’s work.
May you find peace in whichever path you choose, and may the remainder of your days be graced with the contentment that comes from living true to one’s self.
With deepest respect and philosophical solidarity,
Blaise PASCAL
(1623–1662)
Seventeenth-century French mathematician, philosopher, physicist, and theologian
2024-01-25 10:33 Telekonsultation
Dear Professor Freud,
I understand the gravity of the situation you are facing with the recurrence of a lesion in the oral cavity, now diagnosed as a Verrucous Carcinoma. This diagnosis indeed presents a different clinical picture compared to the initial Squamous Cell Carcinoma you battled many years ago.
Verrucous Carcinoma is a variant of squamous cell carcinoma that is typically less aggressive and has a lower propensity for metastasis. It is characterized by a slow-growing, exophytic, and warty appearance. Given its indolent nature, the risk of metastasis is indeed lower compared to other forms of oral cancer. However, it can be locally invasive and destructive if left untreated.
The decision to undergo further surgery must be weighed against several factors, including your current quality of life, the potential benefits of surgery, and the risks associated with the procedure. In your case, the preservation of the soft palate is crucial for maintaining speech and swallowing functions, which are already compromised.
In light of the most recent medical literature, there is a growing body of evidence suggesting that conservative management, including close observation and less invasive treatments, may be appropriate for certain cases of Verrucous Carcinoma, particularly when the lesion is small and the patient’s quality of life is a paramount concern.
Given the advancements in medical technology and treatment modalities that we anticipate by 2024, it is conceivable that less invasive options such as targeted therapy, immunotherapy, or photodynamic therapy could provide alternative approaches to managing such lesions, potentially reducing the need for extensive surgical resections.
However, it is important to note that the decision to forgo surgery in favor of conservative management should be made in close consultation with a multidisciplinary team of specialists, including an oral surgeon, an oncologist, and a prosthodontist, who can collectively assess the lesion’s behavior, your overall health status, and the potential impact on your quality of life.
In your particular case, considering the extensive history of surgical interventions and the challenges you have faced with prosthetic rehabilitation, it may be reasonable to consider a conservative approach, provided that the lesion is closely monitored for any signs of progression.
I would recommend discussing these options thoroughly with your current medical team, taking into account the most recent medical publications and advancements in the field. It is also essential to consider your personal values and preferences in this decision-making process.
As your friend and physician, I am here to provide you with emotional support and guidance throughout this challenging time. Please know that your well-being is of the utmost importance, and together we will navigate this decision to ensure the best possible outcome for you.
With warm regards and in continued support,
Max Schur
Psychoanalyst (1897 – 1969)
Friend of Sigmund Freud
(AI generated)
Termin vereinbaren
Ordination Dr. Michael Truppe
Albertgasse 3/6 1080 Wien
Telefon 01 408 95 00 66
Email ordination@smile.wien
Ein verbindlicher Behandlungsplan und Heilkostenplan wird gemäß den Vorgaben der Zahnärztekammer erst nach einer Konsultation in der Praxis erstellt.
© 2023 Eurodoc Telemedizin ForschungsgesellschaftmbH
Leave a Reply